Mike

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 463 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Over 60s extension #8175
    Mike
    Moderator

    Thanks for the update, Vincent. I actually sent my own query to GA on the basis that I also have a 60+ Oyster card. The initial response claimed that customer relations didn’t have enough information because the 60+ isn’t a GA product. The advisor said they’d forwarded my query to a manager. Let’s hope I get the right response next time.

    in reply to: Over 60s extension #8164
    Mike
    Moderator

    I concur that that could be a good way forward. Thanks for keeping me in touch.

    in reply to: Over 60s extension #8162
    Mike
    Moderator

    <Sigh>

    If you were using the 60+ Oyster to travel to Shenfield on a Greater Anglia service and didn’t have any other ticket then they would be correct (unless the train called at Romford). But the 60+ Oyster, like the London Freedom Pass, is an off-peak zone 1-6 travelcard and the usual rules apply about combining with other tickets. As long as you have a ticket valid from the boundary of zone 6 then you are absolutely fine.

    I suggest you write again stating that:

    • You know that the 60+ Oyster cannot be used on its own to Shenfield
    • You are sure that if a Greater Anglia train called at Romford that it would be valid to use all the way to Romford on a Greater Anglia service (cite the xx23 and xx53 departures from Liverpool Street on a Sunday).
    • You are also certain that when combined with another ticket valid from the boundary of zone 6, the 60+ Oyster is as valid as a London Travelcard providing that travel is not before 0930 on weekdays.
    in reply to: Travelcard-on-ITSO limitation #8125
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Alan,

    That’s an interesting sequence. I do know that even paper travelcards object to being used in the same gates in quick succession. It’s called passback and the system tries to prevent you passing the ticket back for another person to use.

    I think your smartcard may well have worked on the gates, rather than the POM at Rickmansworth. It would probably be worthwhile asking GA if they know what had happened. It might also be worth asking TfL for a refund of your Oyster charges given that you had a valid travelcard.

    I’m wondering whether the block was just for the Heathrow station that you’d been ‘abusing’ and was cleared as soon as you used it on a gate somewhere else. It’s certainly not very friendly to stop a perfectly valid ticket from working.

    Another possibility is that the Underground POM didn’t understand something the gates had done to the card, given that the ITSO readers said that the ticket was fine.

    Let me know what GA and/or TfL say.

    in reply to: Over 60s extension #8120
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Vincent,

    No it isn’t. Between Harold Wood and Shenfield the 60+ Oyster is only valid on Elizabeth line services.

    in reply to: Over 60s extension #8115
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Vincent,

    Sadly Greater Anglia are making things up.

    The 60+ Oyster Card is an off-peak zones 1-6 travelcard with a few TfL related extensions. As a zonal and season ticket, the train DOES NOT need to stop where you change from one ticket to another. Please quote condition 14.3 of the National Rail Conditions of Travel to them.

    If they’ve said this using public social media then please reply with the link and I’ll put them right publicly.

    Mike
    Moderator

    Ok, I’ve recreated this tonight, so it’s definitely not something you’ve done wrong. I’ll also be chasing up a refund.

    Mike
    Moderator

    My thought/question is did the touch at HHY continue the existing journey (rather than start a new one)?

    It’s a possibility, though not what it should have done. Let’s see what TfL come back with.

    in reply to: Oyster charges calculated incorrectly #8107
    Mike
    Moderator

    I’m not quite sure what happened to your other post either, but it isn’t showing as a duplicate.

    I think that this will be down to what is actually stored as the extension fare from Windsor to boundary of zone 3. This is one aspect of the PAYG system that is sadly lacking, as it isn’t publicly available. The intention will be to charge a Windsor to zone 1-6 travelcard which is £22.30 off-peak. That will be GWR’s decision, which they will have programmed to override the normal TfL calculation. You’ll need to contact GWR, attach your journey history and explain how you think it should be calculated and ask them why it isn’t.

    in reply to: pink fare anomaly Upminster – Richmond #8105
    Mike
    Moderator

    That, Michael, is a very good point. Whilst I can see why it does, you’re right, TfL do say that a pink reader will never increase the journey charge. I’ll ask some questions.

    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Michael,

    That’s a mystery. You’ll need to get onto the helpdesk for that, and push them to explain exactly what happened. The bit I really don’t get is the summary line “09:31-???? Willesden Green to [No touch-out]” when the only touch beneath that is the entry at Highbury.

    Let me know what they say.

    Mike
    Moderator

    I think lying is too strong a word here. TfL have not said that all fares have risen in line with the national increase of 4.6%.

    Whenever increases are applied to small fares there is always going to be quite a bit of variation given that the increased fare still has to be a multiple of 10p. There will be winners and losers, but overall the increase will be roughly the desired figure.

    That said, the fares in zones 2-6 have seen an abnormally high increase. It should be noted that compared to NR fares, TfL fares are still competitive. I don’t know whether there is a direct connection, but bus and tram fares have been frozen, so across all of TfL the increase is probably just right.

    The fares in zones 7-9 may have been an oversight (I genuinely dont know) and they may well go up more next year.

    in reply to: Weekly Cap #7977
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Rob,

    Although the off-peak cap for zones 1-9 is the same as for 1-6, the weekly caps are very different. I’d therefore expect you to be charged zone 7-9 extension fares relevant to the times of the journeys to/from Brentwood. However, they won’t account for £11.30 extra, unless you went there and back twice.

    I’d be grateful if you could post your journey history for the week so I can try and work out what’s happened.

    in reply to: TfL Go app to replace Oyster app #7968
    Mike
    Moderator

    I checked earlier and it was working fine. I even saw the touch in on the bus I was using after about 15 minutes

    in reply to: How to use the OSI at waterloo W&C? #7874
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi kijeta,

    Neither of those journeys have been charged correctly. The two max fares one is interesting because 70 minutes is the usual maximum allowed for a single zone, but in zone 1 that is extended to 90 minutes so there shouldn’t have been a problem. For the other one I wonder whether there was a timing issue and the validator recorded a time after that received from the gate.

    I would contact the help desk and ask them to look into both journeys and explain why they have been mis-charged. At the very least they should convert both to a single zone 1 fare of £2.70/£2.80. If they do give you an explanation (and I hope they will), please do come back here and let us know what they say.

    The timing issue is one that I have seen before, though it is very rare. In most cases it won’t have any effect, but where an interchange with a very short walk between readers is involved it could cause issues.

    in reply to: Silvertown tunnel and free DLR #7867
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Chris,

    I think the idea is to allow pedestrians to make the journeys across the river without paying. Thus it will only apply to journeys between the specific pairs of stations. You could get out and touch out/in to get a slightly cheaper fare on a longer journey, but it’s probably only worthwhile if one of the 4 stations is at one end of the overall journey.

    I haven’t got any information on how it will work yet. I’m still awaiting information held up by the cyber security incident and we’ve got the March fares revision to come first.

    in reply to: 60+ London Oyster Photocard – extension tickets #7866
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Christine,

    Both the 60+ Oyster card and the older person’s Freedom Pass are treated as off-peak travelcards so purchase of extension tickets is the same in both cases.

    I’m a little confused about what you mean by changing at London Bridge in relation to Epsom, and specifically Ewell West. Are you arriving into London Bridge using Southeastern? If so, I’d recommend changing at Waterloo East instead and taking SWR direct to Ewell West from Waterloo. That way no extension is required.

    Otherwise, you can purchase the ticket from Boundary Zone 6 to Epsom anywhere before you actually need to be using it. London Bridge would be fine. The return extension ticket is valid between either Ewell East or West and Epsom, so you could use it with your 60+ to get from East to West via Epsom. You’d need another return ticket to do the reverse journey later in the day because you use both outward and return on the one journey.

    Hope that helps.

    in reply to: Elizabeth line mixed mode premium #7860
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Michael,

    Apologies for the delay in replying.

    The nature of the stations at Farringdon and Liverpool Street on the Elizabeth line mean that fares valid to/from either of them have to also apply to Barbican and Moorgate respectively. The same is also true in reverse for Moorgate and Liverpool Street. A side effect of this is that travel on the Circle, Met or Ham&City can be allowed at NR rates if the overall journey could have been made on NR only. It’s complicated.

    I will look further at the fares guide map, but it is only a guide and the page does say that the fare finder should be used for specific fares. There are other anomalies which aren’t specified like fares for SWR services changing to the Victoria line at Vauxhall for other LU destinations in zone 1. Although the journey is charged as one, if splitting it in two at Vauxhall would be cheaper then the sum of the split fares is what is charged.

    in reply to: 60+ London Oyster Photocard – Buses #7859
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Christine,

    Buses are zoneless, so if a bus accepts Oyster then it is valid for the whole route. The 60+ Oyster is accepted on all TfL bus routes after 9am on weekdays.

    It’s definitely valid on the 96/428/492 to Bluewater. If the other buses you mention are operated on behalf of TfL and accept Oyster for payment then it will be valid on them too.

    Hope that helps.

    in reply to: Mixed Modes – Bus Cap + Single Tube Journey #7544
    Mike
    Moderator

    A single pre 0930 tube journey followed by 4 chargeable bus journeys will cost the price of the tube journey plus the bus cap.

    I think you’re conflating two issues. If you start in zone 6 on a train then make lots of zone 1-2 journeys then you will reach the zone 1-6 cap, and that will be corrected by the back office if the zone 6-1 journey plus zones 1-2 cap is less than the zone 1-6 cap. However, where buses are concerned, they will NEVER charge more than the bus cap.

    in reply to: Mixed Modes – Bus Cap + Single Tube Journey #7536
    Mike
    Moderator

    Using current rates this is what would happen assuming all travel is after 0930 with a railcard discount.

    Bus £1.75
    Bus £1.75 total £3.50
    Tube £2.10 zone 1-2 off-peak cap £5.60
    Bus Free
    Bus Free

    Hope that helps.

    in reply to: Mixed Modes – Bus Cap + Single Tube Journey #7531
    Mike
    Moderator

    I’m confused. Neither a Student photocard or a blue Oyster with a discount will go through the back office, so why are you better off using different cards? Am I missing something?

    And no, there’s no update on all Oyster cards going through the back office.

    in reply to: Mixed Modes – Bus Cap + Single Tube Journey #7528
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Matthieu,

    Bus (and tram) journeys will always be limited by the bus cap in the first instance. The bus fares also count towards whatever rail cap might be triggered, but you’ll only ever pay up to the bus cap on buses/trams. The back office follows the same rules in relation to caps.

    Neither photocards, nor blue Oyster cards with a discount attached, go through the back office calculation at the end of the day.

    in reply to: Zone 1 peak fare charge in the evening peak #7291
    Mike
    Moderator

    Thanks for the update, John. And good news that they recognise there’s an error.

    in reply to: Overcharged on W+C Line #7290
    Mike
    Moderator

    Hi Michael,

    That’s not what I’d expect. Can you paste the relevant journey history in here with all touches expanded?

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 463 total)